| SCORES |
|---|
| Day | Date | | Opponent | Result | Location | Venue | Attendance |
|---|
| Sun | 9/24/1916 | A | Cumberland | 9-9 | T | | Cumberland, IN | | |
| Sun | 10/1/1916 | A | Greenwood | 18-7 | W | | Greenwood, IN | | |
| Sun | 10/8/1916 | A | Oaklandon | | | | Oaklandon, IN | | |
| Sun | 10/15/1916 | | Indianapolis Oliver A.C. | | | | Indianapolis, IN | Link Belt Field | |
| Sun | 10/22/1916 | | Shelbyville Independents | 25-0 | W | | | | |
| Sun | 10/29/1916 | | ndianapolis Southeasterns | | - | | Indianapolis, IN | | |
| Sun | 10/29/1916 | A | Brownsburg | 13-6 | W | | Brownsburg, IN | | |
| Sun | 11/5/1916 | H | Indianapolis | 7-0 | W | | Indianapolis, IN | | |
| Sun | 11/12/1916 | A | Cumberland | | | | Cumberland, IN | | |
| Sun | 11/19/1916 | A | Anderson Remys | 5-12 | L | | Anderson, IN | Athletic Park | |
| Thu | 11/30/1916 | N | ndianapolis Southeasterns | 12-0 | W | | Indianapolis, IN | Federal Park | |
| Sun | 12/3/1916 | | ndianapolis Southeasterns | | | | Indianapolis, IN | | |
